The government should not protect the thieves and support a ?black law?, Chief Justice of Pakistan Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry said on Tuesday while heading a full-court hearing of NRO review case.
As 17-member-bench of the Supreme Court on Tuesday continued hearing the review petition on National Reconciliation Ordinance (NRO), the chief justice queried as to how the NRO could be defended despite attorney general?s terming it a black law. The court questioned that when the federal government was not affected by the December 16, 2009 apex court judgment on NRO, why it had filed a review petition.
?The state should not support the black and the stinking law,? the chief justice observed, adding that it was the federation and not a political party that filed the petition, and if someone has any grievance over the court judgement, he or she should come forward instead of the government. Thousands of people took benefit of the NRO but nobody took recourse to the court nor was the court ruling on the ordinance challenged, he added.
?Will the government protect the one who conceal corruption and pardon any such offence?? the chief justice questioned, adding that federal government wants to give ?premier of the corruption? to those who have remained involved in corruption.
Giving arguments before the bench, former federal law minister Babar Awan, whom the court allowed to appeal the case on behalf of the federation on merit, said the government does not even acknowledge the NRO as its repercussions are not good. He further said notices are taken on various news reports; an affront to a lawyer should also be taken note of, adding the federal government believes in transparent and candid accountability. ?I will talk about accountability and not raise a political slogan for the elimination of corruption,? he added.
In his arguments, Awan said that it is a court order that the accused cannot be punished in absentia and that is why closed cases cannot be reopened. Similarly, the SC cannot instruct the federation to reopen cases abroad. Awan maintained that the attorney general in the recent past had written the letter to the (Swiss) authorities without taking advice.
The function of the attorney general for Pakistan was abused, said Babar Awan. He held that the court had ignored the law of past and close transaction, adding that neither the court had authority to reopen overseas cases to investigation nor it can instruct the federation to reopen cases abroad.
The chief justice questioned if the government is backing a law under which corruption flourished. He further said that a federation gains popularity if it does not support a black law and appreciated the current parliament for not approving the NRO.
On a point that NRO was not the deal between two parties but the then cabinet had fully approved it and was legally promulgated by the then president, Justice Jawwad S Khawaja asked Awan whether he wanted to say that NRO was a legal law and should be enacted again. The learned counsel said no there were certain points, which he would not press, and it was on of those.
The chief justice said earlier the federation was insisting that people who have benefited from NRO should be tried in accordance with law, but now the federation defending the corrupt people. He said: ?When the federation is coming to the defence of NRO we are very much disturbed.?
Justice Sarmad Jalal Usmany said: ?If an individual is aggrieved by the judgment of this court then he should come forward but not in the garb of the federation.? Justice Nasirul Mulk remarked that those who benefited from NRO should be tried in accordance with the law.
Justice Saqib Nisar said that the persons who have plundered the national wealth are talking about the past and closed transaction, which undoubtedly apply in this case as documents of corruption are available. The court said that the federation could not protect any thief and criminal.
Babar Awan responded that the PPP has not protected corrupt persons, while in the past people were not only protected, but over protected. He said the federation complain is that they were not heard properly. Justice Jawwad asked Babar Awan: ?We understand you will stand by the stand taken by the federal government earlier. The learned counsel said that the federation stands for accountability and no vengeance.
The Chief Justice asked the former law minister to show a single word from the judgment where the court has condemned the federation or the verdict adversely operating against the federation. He added that the court has rather helped the federal government in recovering plundered and looted national wealth. In Rental Power Plant case Rs4.5, given to Reshma as advance was recovered. He stated the federation led by Yousuf Raza Gilani should not support NRO.
When former law minister pleaded that federation represent the will of the people. Justice Asif Saeed Khan Khosa said you mean to say that federation is for the masses and it has to take care of everyone and in the masses there are thieves and murderers, and if it would not protect them then who would defend them?
Babar Awan said the words that late Benazir Bhutto entered into a deal with Musharraf should be expunged from the NRO judgment. He said late Benazir Bhutto entered into deal not in personal capacity, but was representing the biggest party of the country. He said the PPP the biggest political party represents the will of the people. Justice Sarmad said the federation is not one political party and the chief justice executive of the government does not represent one party but the entire federation. He said if the verdict is against the BB then let come legal heirs of BB come forward.
The chief justice said the president, PM and ministers are for the whole country and not just a party. Justice Muhammad Sair Ali said the PM and ministers take oath not to protect one party but the whole country. Paying tribute to the parliament he said it did not touch the ?stinking law? and it was not validated under the 18th Amendment. He said that people who were affected by the apex court judgment on NRO did not come before the court.
Popular Posts
-
Mid-ranking Pakistani army officials may have known that Osama Bin Laden had a safe house in Pakistan, leaked material appears to indicate. ...
-
Tehreek-e-Insaaf (PTI) chairman Imran Khan said that President Asif Ali Zardari is responsible for the memogate issue, report said on Wedne...
-
Prime Minister Syed Yousuf Raza Gilani has assured Kashmiri leadership that trade will be promoted with India after taking all the stake ho...
-
Pakistan TOA team, silver medalists of the World TOA Championship, urged the government of Pakistan and corporate sector to come forward an...
-
Immigration controller Chulananda Perera says they are members of Tabligh Jamat, a group founded in India to spread the teachings of Islam. ...
-
Sources in the PTI privy to the information regarding inclusion of new faces in the party confided to The Nation on Tuesday that former Sena...
-
A parked car strangely catches fire near the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) rally venue in Karachi EPakistanNews.com reported. According to...
-
The time of Nawaz Sharif gone, The tsunami of PTI can never be stop by the President Zardari and Nawaz. The visit to bhalwal was very succes...
-
Osama Bin Laden surprised everyone in late 1990s when he escaped from the Gulf to hide at an unexpected place: Sudan. Is it that the al-Qae...
-
Former Speaker National Assembly Syed Fakhar Imam and Istaqlal Party President Manzoor Gillani joined Jaago Tehreek on Tuesday, a campaign ...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(109)
-
▼
December
(71)
- Boxing star Amir Khan arrives in Pakistan for tour...
- Cricket: Sri Lanka hope for change of luck
- Football: Celtic trio called to represent Team GB
- Football: Ferguson praises Giggs as United look to...
- If Kayani’s, Pasha’s heads roll, SC may come to re...
- Quaid-i-Azam Day: Float displays country’s cultura...
- To ease freight load: Green light given to buy 14 ...
- Car catches fire near PTI rally in Karachi Venue
- Firdous Ashiq Awan submitted her resignation as Mi...
- Gen. Kayani was not be present at the president’s ...
- Imran Khan ramps up anti-graft revolution
- Protection of minorities rights is a duty of Govt....
- Saudi airlines emergency landing in Karachi
- Thousands of people gathered in PTI Karachi rally
- US suspends drone attacks in Pakistan
- Pakistan won hockey series against China
- 163 bottles of liquor, other items seized
- Abbas, Meshaal to meet in Cairo
- Abidi gets rousing welcome in Karachi
- Agencies role elimination a must: Shahzain
- All parties want thorough probe into memo scandal
- All stakeholders to be taken on board: Gilani
- Anothder Indian prisoner still in jail despite ter...
- Archdiocese of Lahore celebrate 125th anniversary
- ASWJ activist among four killed Karachi violence
- Australian among 7 die in Indian train fire
- Bill against child molestation adopted
- Bush, Blair guilty in Malaysia �war crimes trial'
- Butt, Aamir to appear before court for appeal hear...
- Co-Ed plan irks females
- Condemned consultant points finger at staffers
- Confusion prevails on TTP truce
- Dacoits continue their looting spree in City
- Egyptians gather for mass protest
- Faiza�s painting exhibition opens in City
- Fakhar Imam joins Jaago Tehreek
- FBR asked to address income tax issues
- Five FC men killed in Dera Bugti blast
- Gaddafi son to face trial in Libya
- Gloria Arroyo sued for massacre
- Gold rallies but debt woes dominate
- Govt must not protect thieves: SC
- Govt to form National Security Task Force soon
- �I played hide & seek for personal gains�
- ICJ to be moved against HR abuses in IHK
- Legal fraternity divided over Memogate inquiry
- Letter sans signature invalid, says Khosa
- Llodra-Zimonjic beat �Indo-Pak Express' for first ...
- London giants look to clinch last 16 berths
- Lorgat not to seek extension
- Major POL price hike on the cards
- Man kills childless wife
- Memo casualty
- Munter offers help on memo
- N cancels G,wala public moot over security
- NASA launching 'dream machine' to explore Mars
- No dengue-related deaths anymore
- No high treason against Haqqani
- No reason to rejoice
- Pagara sees no party in power
- Pakistan could become a failed state, says Romney
- Pakistan face Lanka in final ODI today
- Pakistan TOA team seek govt help
- Pakistan, Lanka qualify for Women�s World Cup
- Plea admitted for hearing against CJ oath-taking
- PML-Q notables set to join PTI
- PR Union praises SC verdict in advance
- Promotion of Punjabi language urged
- PTA shelves texting censorship
- Revolt likely against MFN status to India
- S African capital to be renamed
-
▼
December
(71)
Labels
125th
(1)
Aamir
(1)
Abbas
(1)
abducted
(1)
Abidi
(1)
abuses
(1)
activist
(1)
address
(1)
adjustment
(1)
admitted
(1)
adopted
(1)
advance
(1)
Afghanistan
(1)
African
(1)
against
(9)
Agencies
(1)
agenda
(1)
airlines
(1)
alive
(1)
American
(1)
among
(2)
anniversary
(1)
Anothder
(1)
antigraft
(1)
anymore
(1)
Apologise
(1)
appeal
(1)
appear
(1)
Archdiocese
(1)
arrives
(1)
Arroyo
(1)
Ashiq
(1)
Ashraf
(1)
asked
(1)
Asset
(1)
assurance
(1)
attack
(1)
attacks
(1)
Australian
(1)
avoids
(1)
Bangladesh
(1)
beats
(1)
become
(1)
becoming
(1)
before
(1)
berserk
(1)
berths
(1)
between
(1)
Bhalwal
(1)
Blair
(1)
Blairs
(1)
blast
(2)
Blasts
(1)
board
(1)
bottles
(1)
Boxing
(1)
Bugti
(1)
Cairo
(1)
called
(1)
cancels
(1)
capital
(1)
cards
(1)
cargo
(1)
casualty
(1)
catches
(1)
Caught
(1)
celebrate
(1)
Celtic
(1)
censorship
(1)
change
(1)
chieftains
(1)
child
(1)
childless
(1)
China
(1)
clinch
(1)
close
(1)
comments
(1)
Condemned
(1)
Confusion
(1)
Connectivity
(1)
consultant
(1)
containers
(1)
contest
(1)
continue
(2)
corrupt
(1)
could
(1)
countrys
(1)
court
(1)
crackdown
(1)
Cricket
(1)
crimes
(2)
crushes
(1)
cultural
(1)
Dacoits
(1)
deaths
(1)
Deception
(1)
decline
(1)
Deepens
(1)
democracy
(1)
denguerelated
(1)
deports
(1)
derail
(1)
despite
(1)
dinner
(1)
displays
(1)
diversity
(1)
divided
(1)
documents
(1)
Dollar
(1)
dominate
(2)
dream
(1)
drone
(1)
Egyptians
(1)
elect
(2)
elimination
(1)
elite
(1)
Embassy
(1)
emergency
(1)
endorse
(1)
enters
(1)
exhibition
(1)
explore
(1)
Exposes
(1)
Express
(1)
extend
(1)
extension
(1)
failed
(1)
Faizas
(1)
Fakhar
(1)
favour
(1)
females
(1)
Ferguson
(1)
final
(1)
finalised
(1)
finger
(1)
Firdous
(1)
first
(1)
Float
(1)
Football
(2)
Force
(1)
forces
(1)
Former
(1)
found
(1)
fraternity
(1)
freight
(1)
Gaddafi
(1)
gains
(1)
Games
(1)
gather
(1)
gathered
(1)
giants
(1)
Giggs
(1)
Gilani
(3)
given
(1)
Gloria
(1)
Green
(1)
greets
(1)
Group
(1)
guilty
(1)
Gwala
(1)
hands
(1)
Haqqani
(3)
heads
(1)
hearing
(2)
hockey
(1)
hopes
(1)
Imran
(3)
income
(1)
India
(3)
Indian
(3)
IndoPak
(1)
initial
(1)
injured
(1)
inquiry
(1)
insensitive
(1)
invalid
(1)
investigation
(1)
Islam
(1)
Islamic
(1)
issues
(1)
items
(1)
Jaago
(1)
joins
(1)
Kahuta
(1)
Karachi
(6)
Kayani
(1)
Kayanis
(1)
Khosa
(1)
killed
(3)
kills
(1)
Laden
(1)
Lahore
(3)
landing
(1)
language
(1)
Lanka
(6)
launching
(1)
Legacy
(1)
Legal
(1)
Letter
(1)
Libya
(1)
light
(1)
likely
(1)
liquor
(1)
LlodraZimonjic
(1)
London
(1)
looting
(1)
Lorgat
(1)
machine
(1)
Major
(1)
Malaysia
(1)
Mansoor
(1)
massacre
(1)
Match
(1)
media
(1)
Memogate
(1)
merit
(1)
Meshaal
(1)
Minister
(1)
minorities
(1)
missionaries
(1)
molestation
(1)
Moscow
(1)
moved
(1)
Muharram
(1)
Munter
(1)
Muslim
(1)
Mystery
(1)
nation
(1)
National
(2)
notables
(1)
nothing
(2)
oathtaking
(1)
offers
(1)
office
(1)
opens
(1)
Osama
(1)
other
(1)
Pagara
(1)
painting
(1)
pak news
(1)
Pakistan
(14)
Pakistans
(1)
parties
(1)
party
(1)
Pashas
(1)
peace
(1)
people
(1)
personal
(1)
Personnel
(1)
plans
(1)
played
(1)
players
(1)
points
(1)
policy
(1)
polls
(1)
populous
(1)
power
(1)
praises
(2)
present
(1)
President
(1)
presidents
(1)
prevails
(1)
previous
(1)
price
(1)
prisoner
(1)
probe
(1)
Promotion
(1)
protect
(1)
Protection
(1)
protest
(2)
public
(1)
Punjabi
(1)
Purpose
(1)
Qasim
(1)
QuaidiAzam
(1)
qualify
(1)
Quality
(1)
quickly
(1)
quietly
(1)
Qureshi
(1)
rallies
(1)
rally
(2)
Rambo
(1)
ramps
(1)
ransom
(1)
Rawalpindi
(1)
reason
(1)
refers
(1)
Regional
(1)
rejoice
(1)
renamed
(1)
represent
(1)
rescue
(1)
resignation
(1)
responsible
(1)
restoration
(1)
Results
(1)
return
(1)
reveals
(1)
Revolt
(1)
revolution
(1)
rights
(1)
Romney
(1)
rousing
(1)
ruling
(1)
Rupee
(1)
Russia
(1)
Sabir
(1)
sanctions
(1)
Sarkozy
(1)
saturation
(1)
Saudi
(1)
scandal
(2)
Schoolgirl
(1)
schools
(1)
sealing
(1)
Security
(3)
seeks
(1)
seized
(1)
semis
(1)
series
(1)
Shahzain
(1)
shelves
(1)
ships
(1)
Shootings
(1)
Shujaat
(1)
signals
(1)
signature
(1)
slaps
(1)
sought
(1)
specific
(1)
Spirit
(1)
spoils
(1)
spree
(1)
Spying
(1)
Stable
(1)
staffers
(1)
stakeholders
(1)
Stampede
(1)
state
(1)
status
(1)
steals
(1)
steps
(1)
still
(1)
strangled
(1)
StraussKahn
(1)
Stronger
(1)
student
(1)
Study
(1)
submitted
(1)
suspects
(1)
suspends
(1)
Syria
(1)
Syrian
(1)
system
(1)
Tailgate
(1)
taken
(1)
Talks
(1)
Tehran
(1)
Tehreek
(1)
tells
(1)
texting
(1)
their
(1)
thieves
(1)
thorough
(1)
Thousands
(1)
today
(2)
tolerance
(1)
tournament
(1)
Trade
(1)
Traders
(1)
train
(1)
treason
(1)
trial
(2)
troops
(1)
truce
(1)
Truth
(1)
Tsonga
(1)
Tunisia
(1)
Unfolds
(1)
Union
(1)
United
(1)
unlikely
(1)
unmoved
(1)
urged
(1)
vehicle
(1)
Venue
(1)
verdict
(1)
violence
(1)
Visit
(1)
Wapda
(1)
Warid
(1)
welcome
(1)
Wikileaks: Pakistan army officials 'knew of Bin Laden house'
(1)
Windies
(1)
winning
(1)
women
(1)
Womens
(1)
World
(1)
Yemen
(1)
Zardari
(1)
No comments:
Post a Comment